TSB

screen printing => Equipment => Topic started by: Shanarchy on August 06, 2014, 04:27:09 PM

Title: LED exposure times (SPLIT from Anatol LED)
Post by: Shanarchy on August 06, 2014, 04:27:09 PM
Question about exposure times:

I use Ulano EZ Film capillary film
http://www.sourceoneonline.com/item.asp?categoryID=4&sectionID=27&subSectionID=134&subSection2ID=0&subSection3ID=0&attrCatID=0&attrIDs=0&catID=134&catTab=sub_section&productID=2475 (http://www.sourceoneonline.com/item.asp?categoryID=4&sectionID=27&subSectionID=134&subSection2ID=0&subSection3ID=0&attrCatID=0&attrIDs=0&catID=134&catTab=sub_section&productID=2475)

What should I expect for exposure time with a LED unit?
Title: Re: LED exposure times (SPLIT from Anatol LED)
Post by: 244 on August 06, 2014, 05:16:46 PM
Question about exposure times:

I use Ulano EZ Film capillary film
[url]http://www.sourceoneonline.com/item.asp?categoryID=4&sectionID=27&subSectionID=134&subSection2ID=0&subSection3ID=0&attrCatID=0&attrIDs=0&catID=134&catTab=sub_section&productID=2475[/url] ([url]http://www.sourceoneonline.com/item.asp?categoryID=4&sectionID=27&subSectionID=134&subSection2ID=0&subSection3ID=0&attrCatID=0&attrIDs=0&catID=134&catTab=sub_section&productID=2475[/url])

What should I expect for exposure time with a LED unit?
On the Starlight I would guess around 20 seconds.
Title: Re: LED exposure times (SPLIT from Anatol LED)
Post by: Anatolhelp on August 06, 2014, 06:18:46 PM
Question about exposure times:

I use Ulano EZ Film capillary film
[url]http://www.sourceoneonline.com/item.asp?categoryID=4&sectionID=27&subSectionID=134&subSection2ID=0&subSection3ID=0&attrCatID=0&attrIDs=0&catID=134&catTab=sub_section&productID=2475[/url] ([url]http://www.sourceoneonline.com/item.asp?categoryID=4&sectionID=27&subSectionID=134&subSection2ID=0&subSection3ID=0&attrCatID=0&attrIDs=0&catID=134&catTab=sub_section&productID=2475[/url])

What should I expect for exposure time with a LED unit?


We are doing a second round of testing as we speak.....I should have round two results tomorrow.  Round one results were at 18.5 seconds.   But I am not going to tell you that this is the final times.
I would rather not guess!


Title: Re: LED exposure times (SPLIT from Anatol LED)
Post by: Shanarchy on August 06, 2014, 07:31:12 PM
Thank you very much Rich and Terry!

I know results vary depending on white or dyed mesh and waterproof/non-wp film, but this gives me a very good ballpark area of where I can expect to be.

An led unit is definitely on my wish list.
Title: Re: LED exposure times (SPLIT from Anatol LED)
Post by: Dottonedan on August 07, 2014, 12:43:50 AM
For exposure times, one can't say that the times are going to be exactly the same for everyone that uses the same emulsion or carrier device with cap film like this one. I assume that they provide a variety of thicknesses.

There are other factors in play as well. For example, some manually coat 1:1 (on all mesh) while others coat different amounts of times for each different mesh size. A company can't say that their exposure times will be exactly X time because of the variables such as being hand coated, can be much different in emulsion thickness from one shop to the next. A 1:1 coated using the sharp edge will be different than a 1:1 coated with the round edge. Bob may hand coat faster and heavier than Sally.

Toss that in with those who coat a 110 mesh 1:1 and others do 1:2 and then some 2:2 and 2:3.  All one can do is give a good approximate answer based on test and more accurately, would be to provide averages.


Capillary film or products like this kind mentioned will take out a variable of thickness assuming you are comparing the exact same mesh threads/% open area and emulsion thickness. I see they also suggest that this can be used with manual emulsion application as well.
Title: Re: LED exposure times (SPLIT from Anatol LED)
Post by: IntegrityShirts on August 07, 2014, 10:38:45 AM
For exposure times, one can't say that the times are going to be exactly the same for everyone that uses the same emulsion or carrier device with cap film like this one. I assume that they provide a variety of thicknesses.

There are other factors in play as well. For example, some manually coat 1:1 (on all mesh) while others coat different amounts of times for each different mesh size. A company can't say that their exposure times will be exactly X time because of the variables such as being hand coated, can be much different in emulsion thickness from one shop to the next. A 1:1 coated using the sharp edge will be different than a 1:1 coated with the round edge. Bob may hand coat faster and heavier than Sally.

Toss that in with those who coat a 110 mesh 1:1 and others do 1:2 and then some 2:2 and 2:3.  All one can do is give a good approximate answer based on test and more accurately, would be to provide averages.


Capillary film or products like this kind mentioned will take out a variable of thickness assuming you are comparing the exact same mesh threads/% open area and emulsion thickness. I see they also suggest that this can be used with manual emulsion application as well.

Agree to all of this. If we want to get really scientific with it, we need to know what mesh brand and color was used for testing, so we know how thick it is to begin with. Then telling the coating method in addition to an EOM value, and THEN how long it took to reach full exposure all the way through. And of course emulsion type.
Title: Re: LED exposure times (SPLIT from Anatol LED)
Post by: 244 on August 07, 2014, 11:02:36 AM
For exposure times, one can't say that the times are going to be exactly the same for everyone that uses the same emulsion or carrier device with cap film like this one. I assume that they provide a variety of thicknesses.

There are other factors in play as well. For example, some manually coat 1:1 (on all mesh) while others coat different amounts of times for each different mesh size. A company can't say that their exposure times will be exactly X time because of the variables such as being hand coated, can be much different in emulsion thickness from one shop to the next. A 1:1 coated using the sharp edge will be different than a 1:1 coated with the round edge. Bob may hand coat faster and heavier than Sally.

Toss that in with those who coat a 110 mesh 1:1 and others do 1:2 and then some 2:2 and 2:3.  All one can do is give a good approximate answer based on test and more accurately, would be to provide averages.


Capillary film or products like this kind mentioned will take out a variable of thickness assuming you are comparing the exact same mesh threads/% open area and emulsion thickness. I see they also suggest that this can be used with manual emulsion application as well.

Agree to all of this. If we want to get really scientific with it, we need to know what mesh brand and color was used for testing, so we know how thick it is to begin with. Then telling the coating method in addition to an EOM value, and THEN how long it took to reach full exposure all the way through. And of course emulsion type.
Here at M&R we have tested literally hundreds of emulsions, thicknesses, various mesh counts and colors. We have the information available to our customers as needed. Lon Winters also was here for two weeks in the beginning of the project and he alone probably did over 500 different variations. As an independent he can vouch for the information.
Title: Re: LED exposure times (SPLIT from Anatol LED)
Post by: 3Deep on August 07, 2014, 12:02:47 PM
Here at M&R we have tested literally hundreds of emulsions, thicknesses, various mesh counts and colors. We have the information available to our customers as needed. Lon Winters also was here for two weeks in the beginning of the project and he alone probably did over 500 different variations. As an independent he can vouch for the information.

Rich you sound like the Jones 8)...Lon is a top dog read his articles all the time

darryl
Title: Re: LED exposure times (SPLIT from Anatol LED)
Post by: jvanick on August 07, 2014, 12:08:40 PM
Just to compare numbers...

Starlight 2331

SP1400, 156 - white mesh, 2wet over 2wet, round edge scoop coater.
28% relative humidity in the drying room.  screen dried for 24 hours. 82 degrees F.

I'm at 38 seconds for what seems to be a perfect burn.
Title: Re: LED exposure times (SPLIT from Anatol LED)
Post by: blue moon on August 07, 2014, 12:13:09 PM
I will add the Vastex times for the version we tested, 13 sec on everything from 110-330. Aquasol HV, 2+1 with dull side. 25-30% humidity.

pierre
Title: Re: LED exposure times (SPLIT from Anatol LED)
Post by: dirkdiggler on August 07, 2014, 03:26:57 PM
Just to compare numbers...

Starlight 2331

SP1400, 156 - white mesh, 2wet over 2wet, round edge scoop coater.
28% relative humidity in the drying room.  screen dried for 24 hours. 82 degrees F.

I'm at 38 seconds for what seems to be a perfect burn.

Cant believe you just posted this, I am doing this exact test tomorrow, you just saved me some time.  Does that hold up to discharge?
Title: Re: LED exposure times (SPLIT from Anatol LED)
Post by: dirkdiggler on August 07, 2014, 03:27:41 PM
Also, I don't have glass, guess I will be quicker.
Title: Re: LED exposure times (SPLIT from Anatol LED)
Post by: jvanick on August 07, 2014, 03:38:50 PM
I've got glass... would think you'll save some seconds off....

we don't do a lot of long run discharge...

but I can say that it held up just fine to 500 pcs last week with Rutland White Plus....

-- and the screen was still nice and strong when cleaning it off after the print run.

so I have no doubt that it would have held up longer if needed.
Title: Re: LED exposure times (SPLIT from Anatol LED)
Post by: dirkdiggler on August 07, 2014, 05:05:27 PM
I've got glass... would think you'll save some seconds off....

we don't do a lot of long run discharge...

but I can say that it held up just fine to 500 pcs last week with Rutland White Plus....

-- and the screen was still nice and strong when cleaning it off after the print run.

so I have no doubt that it would have held up longer if needed.

awesome news, thanks for that.
Title: Re: LED exposure times (SPLIT from Anatol LED)
Post by: dirkdiggler on August 07, 2014, 05:08:37 PM
I've got glass... would think you'll save some seconds off....

we don't do a lot of long run discharge...

but I can say that it held up just fine to 500 pcs last week with Rutland White Plus....

-- and the screen was still nice and strong when cleaning it off after the print run.

so I have no doubt that it would have held up longer if needed.

with or without hardener?
Title: Re: LED exposure times (SPLIT from Anatol LED)
Post by: jvanick on August 07, 2014, 06:24:15 PM
no hardener... haven't ever used the stuff.
Title: Re: LED exposure times (SPLIT from Anatol LED)
Post by: dirkdiggler on August 07, 2014, 06:27:54 PM
even better news.