TSB
screen printing => Equipment => Topic started by: DannyGruninger on December 27, 2016, 04:33:04 PM
-
I'm sure Rich will chime in as I'm super curious to know the deal with the new M&r oval called the victory. At a recent trade show in turkey the Chinese company cntop were making the claims they have struck a deal with M&r to produce this new machine. I figured this might be a total lie as I just can't imagine rich wanting to produce one of their machines in china. Anyone care to share what's up as something just seems odd here. Maybe it's a way to bring a much cheaper oval solution to the market?
This rendering the cntop place was sharing does not look like traditional M&r screen holders, etc but it looks identical to the Chinese machines found all over alibaba when searching Chinese oval screen printing machines.
-
So many different machines going on here.
MHM screen holders, ROQ head lifts, M&R paint....
-
M&R has had things going on for years in other country's, Different stuff than we know about M&R here in the US.
IN addition, I have often been surprised even when working there myself, to find out we have been doing this or built that. I've seen things that were put out as new technology from competitors at shows, letting things get fumbled around on for the first few years by customers while we have had it for 3-4 years (or more) before them being perfected, but M&R never put it out there first. First to Market is great for "ideas" but for machinery, not so much.
-
Pretty sick looking machine though!!
-
Pretty sick looking machine though!!
Eh, it's got China written all over it.
Here it is complete with (I'm assuming) bootleg Disney prints sporting those wackjob fleamarket color schemes.
https://qdhtyinhuashebei.en.alibaba.com/product/60530524477-218130312/Professional_Better_than_M_R_Oval_Silk_Screen_Printing_Machine_for_T_shirt_Textile.html
-
Pretty sick looking machine though!!
Eh, it's got China written all over it.
Here it is complete with (I'm assuming) bootleg Disney prints sporting those wackjob fleamarket color schemes.
https://qdhtyinhuashebei.en.alibaba.com/product/60530524477-218130312/Professional_Better_than_M_R_Oval_Silk_Screen_Printing_Machine_for_T_shirt_Textile.html (https://qdhtyinhuashebei.en.alibaba.com/product/60530524477-218130312/Professional_Better_than_M_R_Oval_Silk_Screen_Printing_Machine_for_T_shirt_Textile.html)
Hahaha! The title says professional "Better" than M&R press. I guess if you're going say it's "better than" and you have to pick one of the major competitors it's apparently M&R even in China. LOL. But isn't this the same press as shown above? If so, why the title of "better than". Confused.
-
funny the alibabah looks like a blue Sroque
-
Yea, some of the items are identical while other area not so much. The one from the alibabah website might be a Chinese knock off of a Chinese manufacturer building and distributing for M&R in China. Who knows. Honestly, I don't know how they each handle these knock off issues (within China). One Chinese manufacturer can knock off another Chinese manufacturer. How do they handle that? Just go about their business as if nothings going on? Seems like.
-
Yea, some of the items are identical while other area not so much. The one from the alibabah website might be a Chinese knock off of a Chinese manufacturer building and distributing for M&R in China. Who knows. Honestly, I don't know how they each handle these knock off issues (within China). One Chinese manufacturer can knock off another Chinese manufacturer. How do they handle that? Just go about their business as if nothings going on? Seems like.
Not the same press. No CE no UL components and completely different electronics. Even cylinders are EMC instead of SMC. All copies look alike but definitely don't run alike. We at this point don't even sell this unit in China or the States.
-
I think I saw RW in the back of one of the pics. ;D
-
I think I saw RW in the back of one of the pics. ;D
In pajamas and night cap
-
I think I saw RW in the back of one of the pics. ;D
In pajamas and night cap
Bouncing on a bed with Jeff Saxbys check.
-
I think I saw RW in the back of one of the pics. ;D
In pajamas and night cap
Bouncing on a bed with Jeff Saxbys check.
let's keep it a little more vague. ??? Lotta water under the bridge, but we do have some basic tenets to still follow.
-
Thanks Andy for keeping that integrity here. Besides any new equipment options should be evaluated and given a chance before the negativity starts.
-
I see pictures from fespa that this oval is there. Looks identical to the Chinese company cntop oval. What's the story is this an M&r or a Chinese cntop?(as to where the machine is being machined, welded, assembled, etc)
-
I see pictures from fespa that this oval is there. Looks identical to the Chinese company cntop oval. What's the story is this an M&r or a Chinese cntop?(as to where the machine is being machined, welded, assembled, etc)
http://www.mrprint.com/news/12227-mnr-introduces-the-victoryone-oval-press (http://www.mrprint.com/news/12227-mnr-introduces-the-victoryone-oval-press)
http://www.mrprint.com/equipment/victoryone-automatic-oval-screen-printing-press (http://www.mrprint.com/equipment/victoryone-automatic-oval-screen-printing-press)
-
HMMM. Very interesting press. When it will it be available State side?
-
Dannys got a hard on for this one. LOL
-
HMMM. Very interesting press. When it will it be available State side?
They are available as of today here in the states as well.
-
Dannys got a hard on for this one. LOL
Not really, just wanting accurate info so people can make informed decisions. I would sure as hell want to know if my machine was manufactured in China vs USA when I'm buying from a usa company.
What is the difference between this machine and a stryker?
Why would someone buy this machine over a stryker?
Why would m&r go with an entirely different pallet system and print head when they've said their current solution(stryker) is the best?
Is this machine RL certified ?
I'm just scratching my head as to why this oval is coming out when the stryker just came out, whats the reason?
-
Dannys got a hard on for this one. LOL
Not really, just wanting accurate info so people can make informed decisions. I would sure as hell want to know if my machine was manufactured in China vs USA when I'm buying from a usa company.
What is the difference between this machine and a stryker?
Why would someone buy this machine over a stryker?
Why would m&r go with an entirely different pallet system and print head when they've said their current solution(stryker) is the best?
Is this machine RL certified ?
I'm just scratching my head as to why this oval is coming out when the stryker just came out, whats the reason?
it does say that it is in partnership with a Chinese factory, so I would guess it is made there.
what is RL certification?
pierre
-
Typo I meant to say UL instead of RL
-
M&R has been around for a long time and is responsible for a lot of great stuff. I am sure they have their reasons. And to assume something that is made in China is bad for some reason is weird. Look at your Iphone for example. Anyway, the limited time I was lucky to spend at M&R one day the sheer amount of equipment shipping to China was insane. It was staggering how much was going there. So in a business sense it would be smart to have a factory there to produce and sell there instead of slow boating it across the ocean. For any change in equipment features that is their decision and maybe meeting what the their customers are wanting. I do not run an international company so maybe offering something in China in today's world market it makes sense to offer it everywhere.
-
M&R has been around for a long time and is responsible for a lot of great stuff. I am sure they have their reasons. And to assume something that is made in China is bad for some reason is weird. Look at your Iphone for example. Anyway, the limited time I was lucky to spend at M&R one day the sheer amount of equipment shipping to China was insane. It was staggering how much was going there. So in a business sense it would be smart to have a factory there to produce and sell there instead of slow boating it across the ocean. For any change in equipment features that is their decision and maybe meeting what the their customers are wanting. I do not run an international company so maybe offering something in China in today's world market it makes sense to offer it everywhere.
Not sure that I or anyone said Chinese made is junk. In fact I think quite the opposite as everything I see the chinese make is damn near awesome. This has nothing to do with that. I'm curious as to what the difference between this machine and the stryker is? I would be really pissed off at Roq if I just spent 200K on my oval only for them to turn around and make another cheaper version in china. I'm trying to understand because it seems like the stryker is brand new basically and now there is this. Does that mean something is wrong with the stryker? Again just trying to understand as I cannot wrap my head around it. What is the price difference and feature comparison between the two machines is what I'd like to know as I said it does not make sense to me.
-
They just released a picture on Facebook six hours ago for the FESPA trade show! it's called the victory one
http://www.mrprint.com/news/12227-mnr-introduces-the-victoryone-oval-press (http://www.mrprint.com/news/12227-mnr-introduces-the-victoryone-oval-press)
-
I kind of see it like this.
We love our Challenger III and it would be awesome if all our presses were C III,s but in reality the sportsmans do a great job for us at a great price point. Kind of like the roq you. Do you really need a full blown press to be a dedicated sleeve or pocket press to run 1 to 4 colors or will an economy press print just as well at a fraction of the price?
Now M&R has an oval that is more in line with the Sportsman pricing (I hope) rather than the Challenger pricing and features so many people can get into a 20 plus color press that could not have before.
-
The machine is already made in China for the Chinese market so I don't think it's intended for them.
The frame holders are straight MHM and the head lifts are straight Roq. The Chinese are more than capable of
producing quality but in my experience when it's a knockoff that's usually not the case. I could be wrong,
and imitation is the sincerest form of flattery.
As far as I can tell none of it is compatible with other M&R machines. Pinned frames so no tri-loc.
Price and the continued threat of a pvc ban is my guess. Though how cheap it will be once the orange one hears of it
is anybodies guess.
Odd route for blue at the very least.